There is a lot going on so I am going to jump right in.
For me, I am looking at 2025 and seeing significant storm clouds. The Commercial Real Estate markets across the nation appear to be rotting in front of our eyes. Minneapolis and St. Paul are a microcosm. Recent auction and sales of both multi family and office structures have produced prices well beneath anything close to tax assessed or assumed market place values. Beyond losses for the owners as well as banks, think about the adjustments in the real estate taxes that will have to occur. In more and more cases, the level of delinquent taxes on commercial real estate are exploding. The level of lost or significantly delayed tax collections will devastate local government budgets which rely heavily on the taxes from real estate. The final outcome here will likely be a shift of reliance from commercial real estate to other forms of revenue growth to home owners and increased sales tax.
If you are in a financial institution and have not begun to review, in detail, your commercial real estate portfolio, you are fast falling behind. Every one of your accounts should be reviewed now. If possible, update the rent rolls and get the new leases. If that is not possible, complete a sight visit immediately. Look at the condition, count the vacancies. Take photos, including of the tenant list in the directory, and compare them to prior visits. Document your file with your findings. Stress test the cash flow with any new information that you have. Honestly assess the new estimated value and if warranted, order a new valuation to support your findings. Reconsider the risk rating, moving it down as necessary. Do this now before your next exam, it will help you in avoiding the stress and anguish many banks are experiencing now that the examiners have shown up.
The level of Federal Debt being and proposed to be funded by bonds in the near future is unprecedented. The fiscal spending over the past year has to be covered and tax revenues are not even close. The proposed bond levels will undoubtedly push up long term interest rates as the auction level grows in 2025. This does not bode well for an improved economy that needs long term investment in the real estate market, new equipment or even vehicle sales at lower interest rates.
The October ISM report on manufacturing clearly shows a continued malaise. The index fell from 47.5 to 46.5. This is the lowest point in over a year and shows that manufacturing is falling at a faster rate. Throughout the report, there was no area that was reflective of any improvement. In fact the forward indicators like new orders and back logs were all pointing to a continuation of the decline. The pricing index moved from 48.3 to 54.8. This was the most dramatic turn in prices since 2022. This likely is the very early warning sign that prices overall are going to start to spike in 2025.
I purposefully avoided the jobs report from this past week. There were too many variables that impacted the employment picture over the past month. Between Boeing, the storms that devasted the South East, and government hiring, the impacts are not reflective of the economy over the long run. We will look at October as an aberration and will need to bridge the numbers.
On Wednesday the third quarter GDP first look was released. At 2.8%, on its face, the growth level looks acceptable. When you dig into the number and recognize the level of gasoline that was thrown into the economic fire from July 1 to September 30 by the massive amounts of fiscal spending, you have to scratch your head. Had the money supply continued to constrict, had fiscal spending remained in at a sane level, the economy likely would have been well under 2%. In that event, the Fed cut in rates by ½% as well as expected future cuts seems to make sense. If after the election, fiscal spending suddenly is cut, the economy could rapidly decelerate, leaving a recession by mid to late 2025. Something to at least think about.
Have a great week.





